CalgaryPolitics.com Debate

9
August 4, 2010 - By

If you’ve ever watched a Canadian political forum, it goes pretty much like this:  The moderator asks a question, and the candidates, in rotation, answer.  One by one, they either tack onto an opponent’s answer, or refer to another one to explain how theirs is different, but there is no real rebuttal process or the point-counterpoint dynamic that exists in a real debate.  Hell, even those friendly arguments at the bar about Mac vs. PC look more like a formal debate than these.

However, it is difficult to hold a real debate because, well, could you imagine the point-counterpoint complexities of a dozen candidates?  I guess you could hold debates of 2 individuals and ensure every candidate faces every other candidate… but then you would have 66 individual debates.

So how do you really get a chance to put all the candidates in one spot, let them argue with each other but also have a moderator who asks specific questions to each of them as well?  And how do you allow the audience to chime in with follow ups to individual candidates?

Enter the debate style of the social media world: The CalgaryPolitics.com Twibate series.

Alberta has one of the most active political twitter communities in North America.  Most Calgary aldermanic and mayoral candidates are on some form of social media, and many are using it to talk directly to potential voters.  The number of tweets with the #yycvote hashtag is over 120 per day, on average (Source: All Tweets with #yycvote between July 24, 2010 and August 1, 2010)

So what is a Twibate?

Loosely defined, it’s organized chaos.  The plan is to have a set of candidates all on Twitter at once, and at regular intervals, the moderator (@CalgaryPolitics) will ask pre-set questions developed by The Best Political Team in the Blogosphere™.

Candidates will answer the questions by the moderator, but will also be able to reply to each other, reply to follow-up questions asked by tweeps, and carry on lengthy discussions about policy in a public forum.

The magic of the Twibates is that everyone can participate (even the candidates who are not part of that night’s debate can chime in.  Everyone can ask questions.  Everyone can debate.  We’re hoping a lot of mini debates happen and that it leads to a lot of conversation through the electoral period.

You can, of course, only follow the candidates you want to, or follow the whole Twibate hashtag (yes, we’re giving it its own hashtag, just so it will be easy for anyone following the Twibate to follow)

Let’s be clear – this is going to be absolutely nuts.  There will be threads going every which way and lots of questions/answers. Candidates, you may be answering followups for the following weeks, depending on how these threads go.  But the point of this is to spark debate and discussion on Twitter, leading up to the Calgary civic elections.

Candidates are encouraged to have written notes prepared online and be ready to link to them.  While twitter only allows for sound bites, we want this to be an opportunity for you to showcase your plans, as
well.  Feel free to link them, and highlight certain points using twitter.

I think this is a great opportunity to showcase candidates, play to direct democracy, and show the rest of the political world what truly is possible now in the world of social media.

CalgaryPolitics.com will, in the near future, publish the details of the Twibate Series – specifically, when each set of candidates will debate, when the Twibates will happen, and how you can follow and participate.

Welcome to the future of politics.

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention CalgaryPolitics.com Debate « CalgaryPolitics.com -- Topsy.com

  • Enlightened Savage

    Looking forward to it – in contrast with some groups, that feel they should be able to grill candidates behind closed doors, this promises to be the ULTIMATE in public access. What's more democratic than being able, as a citizen, to ask a follow-up question directly to a candidate whose answer leaves you wanting more? There's no “I'm sorry, we've used the 30 seconds allotted for your entire fiscal policy statement”. :)

  • http://djkelly.ca DJ Kelly

    Is Calgary ready for an hours long debate followed by the weeks long follow-up? I think we are if it means getting some discussion about the future of Calgary actually happening!

  • anonymous

    Just remember, not everyone has a computer or an internet connection. I would suggest that calling this “the ultimate in public access” is very elitist of you… except that anyone with a library card has access to an internet-connected computer.

  • http://djkelly.ca DJ Kelly

    It bears noting that to be the “ultimate” you only need to be the best of what's available, not the best of what could be available.

  • http://kirkschmidt.myopenid.com/ Kirk Schmidt

    I should probably add that you do not need a Twitter account in order to “watch” the Twibate. You will be unable to post, but there are a number of tools out there that allow you to see all posts, and even pause updating until you have time to read what is already on the screen.

    In the coming weeks I will be publishing (and sending to candidates) a guideline for candidates for the Twibate, which will include more defined dates and times, etiquette/guidelines for the Twibate in general, and recommendations for optimizing your ability to participate.

  • http://twitter.com/robvh2 Robert Vanden Heuvel

    The 140 character limit (less when you consider tags, etc) doesn't allow nearly enough room for a decent debate. Facebook would be a much better forum. Each debate question could be a new post and the candidates respond in the comments area. That keeps the various issues organized. Twitter would be a chaotic collection of useless soundbites at best.

  • http://kirkschmidt.myopenid.com/ Kirk Schmidt

    A Facebook debate would definitely be interesting for having much more comprehensive answers per post. I would argue, though, that Facebook has its own deficiencies (or, perhaps, there's some things Twitter does better – for example, if you only care about the answers from any candidate in Ward 1, you could create a list or a search to view only those).

    However, as I mentioned in the post – we will be encouraging candidates to have written material prepared and have links to them ready, so that they can talk to their policies rather than re-writing the whole thing onto the post.

    Furthermore, I would hope that citizens use the sounds bites and points made to challenge the candidates on a larger scale after the Twibate. This will get general ideas out there, and would hopefully create dialogue on other mediums, such as Facebook, candidates' websites, mainstream media, etc.

    Effectively, the Twibate is both an experiment in social media AND a launching pad for ideas which, hopefully, will turn into much more comprehensive conversations after-the-fact.

  • Pingback: Twibate Dates and Details « CalgaryPolitics.com